Top Rated Auto Lot In Spearfish
Your Spearfish, SD Used Car Dealer - Auto Choice
We have been open for over 24 years and we are still locally owned and operated. Auto Choice was founded to give our neighbors a dealership where vehicles are honestly inspected, fairly priced, and nobody pressures you into anything. It still operates that way today.
24+
Years on Heritage Drive
300+
Positive local reviews
9
Lending partners
100%
Inspected before listing
What's on the Lot
Used Trucks, Cars, SUVs, and Vans
A genuine mix, because our customers are a genuine mix: Black Hills State students who need something dependable and cheap to run, ranchers who need a truck that works, and families who need three rows and a heater that actually gets warm.
- Efficient commuter cars for the drive to campus, the clinic, or Rapid City.
- Half-ton and heavy-duty pickups for ranch and construction work.
- AWD crossovers and body-on-frame 4x4s for winter roads and trailheads.
- Work vans for the trades and family vans with sliding doors.
Find Us
Top Rated Auto Lot In Spearfish
We are at 321 S. Heritage Drive, right off I-90 — easy to get to whether you are a BHSU student walking distance from campus or commuting back from Rapid City.
321 S. Heritage Drive, Spearfish, SD 57783 — just off Jackson Boulevard, a few minutes from I-90 exit 14.
Work Trucks for Local Jobs
We keep heavy-duty and half-ton pickups on the lot for the ranches and construction outfits around Spearfish and Belle Fourche. If the truck is going to be used for ag work, ask us about South Dakota “Construction Plates” — we will walk you through whether your use qualifies and what it means for your registration.
Brands We Carry
Ford and Ram for the work trucks. Jeep and Subaru when traction is the priority. Toyota and Honda for commuters that just keep going. Our inventory changes throughout the day, so what is here this morning may be gone by dinner — and something new is usually taking its place.
Service
Auto Choice Service Center
South Dakota temperature swings are hard on a vehicle. Cold mornings pull on a battery and a starter, fluids thicken up, and snow and road treatment work on everything underneath.
We inspect brakes with the local grades in mind — the canyon, the hills out of town, the long descents that heat a brake system up. And we handle the routine work: oil changes, tire rotations, brake service, battery replacement, and wheel alignments.
Why Us
Why Spearfish Locals Buy Vehicles At Auto Choice
Twenty-four years in business and more than 300 positive local reviews. That does not happen by accident, and it does not happen from advertising.
We are not a big, flashy dealership and we are not trying to be. We sponsor Little League and the Black Hills Roundup. Our goal is simple: sell a good local car to somebody who is going to be driving past us for the next ten years.
- Independently owned and locally operated — not a franchise.
- Every vehicle inspected before it is listed, with the history report up front.
- Nine lending partners, including two local credit unions, plus rent-to-own.
- Trade-ins appraised on the spot, and we buy outright with no purchase necessary.
Reviews
What Our Neighbors Say
Twenty-four years on Heritage Drive and more than 300 positive local reviews. Most of our business still comes the same way it always has — somebody told a neighbor.
“Third truck we've bought from Auto Choice. They had the history report ready before I even asked, and they told me what the truck would need in the next 20,000 miles instead of letting me find out on my own.”
“I needed something that would start in January and get me over to Rapid City every day. They put me in an AWD crossover, showed me the real payment before I signed anything, and handled the title paperwork.”
“Credit wasn't great after a rough couple of years. The rent-to-own program got me driving the same week and nobody made me feel bad about it.”
Areas Served
Serving the Northern Hills
Belle Fourche, Lead, Deadwood, Sturgis, Rapid City, Sundance and northeast Wyoming — people make the drive because it is worth it.
South Dakota
- Spearfish
- Belle Fourche
- Sturgis
- Whitewood
- Lead
- Deadwood
- Central City
- St. Onge
- Newell
- Rapid City
- Box Elder
Wyoming
- Sundance
- Beulah
- Hulett
- Gillette
We handle South Dakota title and registration through the Lawrence County Treasurer, and out-of-state titling for Wyoming and Montana buyers.
See What's on the Lot
Our inventory updates throughout the day. Come walk it, drive something on the roads you actually use, and bring your trade for an appraisal while you are here.
Or call us at (605) 642-2886 — toll-free (888) 798-0284.